Another Month, Another Leak

 Jane Kelsey on Wikileaks latest leak 

‘The governments negotiating the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement need to wave a white flag and agree to release the whole draft text’, said University of Auckland Professor Jane Kelsey as another leaked chapter was posted on Wikileaks

There are two new leaked documents. One is a consolidated or chairs’ text of the environment chapter. The cover page says ministers asked the Canadian chair of the environment working group to prepare the text. It is dated 24 November 2013, the last day of the Salt Lake City round that preceded the December meeting of TPPA ministers in Singapore.

The second document is the Canadian chairs’ report that sums up the positions of the other countries, including New Zealand, on the proposed new text and shows what countries disagree with which provisions. 

The environment chapter addresses a wide range of issues from overfishing, shark-finning and protecting endangered species to recognising indigenous rights over traditional knowledge and genetic resources.

Professor Kelsey describes the text as ‘weak and unenforceable, hardly the 21st century standard-setter the cheerleaders have been claiming for the TPPA. Most of the provisions are aspirational and it has no teeth to enforce what limited obligations there are’.

‘This confirms our expectations that the “gold standard” rules are only for the corporations, not to protect people and the planet.’ 

The leak also provides insights into how ministers are trying to break through the deadlock in key chapters, of which environment is one.

Professor Kelsey observes that ‘asking one country to prepare a new text “on their own responsibility” to present to the rest is a controversial strategy used at the World Trade Organisation to isolate countries that are holding outlier positions, even ones that are critically important for them’.

‘Ironically, the US is the sole standout on a number of issues, notably its demand that countries found to be breaching the environment chapter should face trade sanctions.’ 

The leaked text falls far short of the standards set in a May 2007 deal between President George W Bush and the Democrat-controlled Congress, which the US has required in all subsequent free trade pacts. 

‘This poses a major problem for President Obama’, Kelsey said. ‘Last week the administration tabled a Bill in Congress seeking fast track negotiating authority for the TPPA and other agreements. It is already struggling for support. This environment chapter will strengthen opposition from many Democrats and force Obama to rely even more for support from hostile Republicans.’ 

In an overview analysis of the text Professor Kelsey observes that New Zealand opposes enforceable rules. New Zealand has not achieved effective disciplines on fisheries subsidiaries that are seen to contribute to overcapacity and overfishing. It also does not support proposals from Peru, Malaysia, Vietnam and Brunei that would give indigenous peoples stronger rights over traditional knowledge and genetic resources – in line with the recommendations of the Waitangi Tribunal’s WAI 262 report on traditional knowledge. 

Waihopai 2014


Waihopai & the GCSB spy on new Zealanders
The NSA spies on everyone .


People from all around New Zealand will be converging on the super-secret Waihopai satellite interception spybase, in Marlborough, on Saturday January 25th.

The Anti-Bases Campaign’s activities will start with a public meeting at 10 a.m., at the

“Spies And Lies: Waihopai & Global Spying"
Nativity Church Hall
76 Alfred Street
Blenheim

The speakers are:

  • Steffan Browning MP, Blenheim’s Green MP,
  • John Minto of Global Peace and Justice Auckland & 
  • Warren Thomson of Anti-Bases Campaign 


The purpose of the public meeting is to discuss the wider issues of spying, to put Waihopai into context.
.
To be followed by a gathering at 

the Waihopai spy base’s main gate on 
Waihopai Valley Road 
1.30 p.m. 

with speeches from 2 p.m.

2013 was the year where it was conclusively proven that the GCSB & Waihopai have been illegally spying on New Zealanders for years (as ABC has said since the spy base was first announced in 1987). So what did the Government do? It passed laws (the GCSB & TICS Acts) to legalise the crime. And 2013 was the year that, thanks to Edward Snowden, it was conclusively proven that the US National Security Agency (NSA – the GCSB’s boss) has been, and still is, spying on everyone everywhere.

So this is ABC’s theme this time – in addition to our longstanding assertion that Waihopai is NZ’s key contribution to America’s global spying machine. Waihopai is a US spy base in all but name, operating on NZ soil, a vital outpost of the American Empire. Simultaneously, the US is pushing for a Free Trade Agreement, via the Trans Pacific Partnership Agreement (which the US wants to be concluded ASAP this year) as NZ’s “reward” for having supplied our troops as cannon fodder in Afghanistan, and for hosting the Waihopai spy base.

The GCSB has been given nearly three quarters of a billion dollars of taxpayers’ money in the past quarter of a century. The 2013/14 budget is $59 million, plus another $35 million was recently spent on new GCSB headquarters in Wellington. It is a criminal waste of taxpayers’ money. Waihopai’s operations are exempt from the Privacy Act, Crimes Act and Official Information Act, and MPs are specifically prohibited from investigating activities of the GCSB.

Waihopai does not operate in the national interest of New Zealand. In all but name it is a foreign spy base on NZ soil, paid for with hundreds of millions of our tax dollars; it spies on New Zealanders; and involves us in America’s global spying machine. Waihopai must be closed. (For details on Waihopai and what it does, go to the Anti-Bases Campaign Website)